
INGLOURIOUS BASTERDS
2009/Director: Quentin Tarantino/Writer: Quentin Tarantino
Cast: Brad Pitt, Mélanie Laurent, Christoph Waltz, Eli Roth, Michael Fassbender, Diane Kruger, Daniel Brühl
I have to admit that I really did not enjoy this Quentin Tarantino film at all but I really, really wanted to. I waited for this with high expectations. In fact I still want to be able to write something about it and sound like I am one of the special people (one of the many people) who got the film’s ‘message’ and consider it to be Taratino’s best work to date. I read that the film got an eight minute standing ovation at the 62nd Cannes Film Festival. From me it got shut off wit my remote and finished a couple nights later out of a sense of obligation (maybe to just write something abut it here, the worst reason to watch a film maybe) more than a passion to see the rest of the story. And while I am at it I will have to say I was let down, though much less so, with his Grindhouse Death Proof feature as well. The last thing I liked by the guy was Jackie Brown and just feel he has lost his once marvelous mojo since that film. I will be direct. Inglourious Basterds had too much banter and not enough gutsy action in it for me. Sure Tarantino could once create riveting dialog about Quarter Pounders in France but the dialogs in Basterds, a script he reportedly worked on for nearly a decade, simply drug on and on and lacked any of the wit and humor one watches his earlier films over and over for.

I really had my hopes up -maybe too high-for this film and so I probably am all the more miserable for having them dashed so unexpectedly. I had been reading about Tarantino doing a WW II combat film loosely based on The Dirty Dozen and Where Eagles Dare for a couple years now and could hardly wait. I imagined all the cool dialog and character conflicts and humor that such a story could allow but I also pictured actual combat. Guns shooting people. Of course that does happen here and there for tortuously brief moments but the actual combat and battles seems to be done with sly innuendos and witty jabs over the dinner table than in a battle field or shell blasted side-street somewhere. At nearly three hours long I kept losing interest in the characters. Brad Pitt as Tennessee born Lt. Aldo Raine (maybe a play on action character actor Aldo Ray) is the leader of the Basterds which is a group of specially trained commandos that have been raising hell behind enemy lines with the Nazis since the early days of the war. I am not sure how I feel about the idea that the group is made up solely of Jews, except for Raine, bent on revenge and terror. I do not see it as remotely necessary to make the group all Jewish and if there is some message here I missed it. I also do not like the way the Basterds simply come into existence with little explanation of who they are as individuals. In fact the Basterds all but vanish from the middle part of the story while a series of painfully long and drawn scenes occur one after the other in restaurants and coffee shops between various Nazis and French citizens. And to add to the agony that the majority of the dialog occurs in German and French. That is okay for the most part but well over half of the dialog in the film is in French or German and the puns and clever Tarantino phrases that make the scenes in Pulp Fiction and Kill Bill quotable and priceless are all lost here. There is, for an example, a scene of a group of spies in a tavern who have as their guest an uninvited SS officer who causes stress levels among the group to jump off of the chart. The problem is not that the dialog here is in another language than English but that it goes on for too damned long and when things finally erupted in gunfire I was in a state where I just did not care.

Some people have said the film was too violent but I feel it was not violent enough. There is not enough action and mayhem to make up for the long attempts at Tarantinoesque banter in German or French. While actor Christoph Waltz is simply great as the Jew Hunting Nazi Col. Landa I just was not excited by any of the other character’s or the actors performances. In particular I was utterly bored by Brad Pitt’s weary performance. He is one of my favorite actors and I was picturing some sort of Lee Marvin type character here and it was maybe the worst performance of this fine actor’s career. And like the joke from Annie Hall about the bad food at some restaurant in the Catskills (paraphrased): A: The food here is so bad. B: Yes. And such small portions. I did not like his performance and he was simply not on the screen enough. I though the film was about him and his elite squad of killer Jews but they the people one sees the least. Eli Roth as the baseball bat welding ‘Jew Bear’ is goofy at best. Definitely not imposing or larger than life. Tarantino has said that this was actually a Spaghetti Western with a WW II backdrop. Well crap man, just make a Spaghetti Western then. Or maybe not. Why muck that classic genre up as well. What the hell happened here? I wanted to see Nazis being blasted with a Tommy Gun and Panzer tanks terrorizing tough talking G.I.s from Brooklyn, instead I get to see Nazi’s put out cigarettes in cheese cake and wax philosophically about rats and squirrels. Hey, lots of people like this one. I would, and have, watched many previous Tarantino effort more than once. Including Death Trap. Hell I love that scene where that gal’s leg soars through the night sky. But, and say this with regret, this is one Tarantino film that I will not watch again. Am I saying that it is totally terrible film and not worth a watching? No way and let me clear on that point before shifting gears for a bit. It is, in the end, a Tarantino film and even a bad Tarantino film is better than most other films coming out of either Hollywood of the foreign market these days. And in the end will I probably give the film another go someday… yea I probably will. I am still in the bitter let down phase right now. Like the trusting girl who has sworn off men after she finds her boyfriend in bed with her best friend. But eventually we all regain some faith in men, humanity and Quentin. My opnion is just that, my opinion and is not the final word on anything.
But there are a couple other war dramas I have seen more than a couple times and will probably see again. These films may have inspired Tarantino’s war drama but his story falls way short of at least two of these great war epics, The Dirty Dozen and Iron Cross. The third film is not a great film but is notable in that it was the inspiration for the title of Tarantino’s dreary adventure. That film is called, with proper spelling, The Inglorious Bastards. Lets take a brief look at those films before leaving this subject behind. At the end of the article I hope I will have something positive to say about Inglourious Basterds. I may just need some time to reflect while saying something about these other films.

READ THE REST OF THIS FASCINATING ARTICLE HERE >>